Featured SOS Diary
Children Constructing Peace Education
by Walter Enloe, Ph,D.
www.learnpeace.org.uk
In view of their tendencies toward passivity, authoritarianism,
and lack of authentic dialogue between children and teachers,
their structural forms of contrived time and space, and their
artificial separation of knowledge into distinct subjects,
is it possible for schools to contribute authentically to
a peace education? Ideally peace education’s content should
develop from the students’ own interests, ideals, and hopes.
But this peace education ideal seems hard to implement in
schools. There seems to be a built-in idea that if you are
to teach somebody something, the content must be determined
in advance. This kind of prescribed instruction is so deeply
ingrained in everyone who works in schools that they are unused
to conducting a dialogue that attempts to include the pupils’
own subjective reactions towards the world. Walter Enlow,
describes how some pupils and teachers ovecame some of these
limitations.
I want to share with you an experiment we
began in 1985 at the International School in Hiroshima, Japan,
which speaks directly to fostering an educational environment
in which students actively engage the world and help determine
educational content based upon their ideals, hopes, and interests.
Moreover, I want to share with you the creative extensions
and subsequent development of a variety of peace education
projects in which children learn through dialogical experiences
in peace education and not vicariously about peace. These
are the stories of children having wonderful ideas and of
teachers who helped them enact them through lived experiences.
From 1980 to 1988 I was the principal and
a teacher at Hiroshima International School. This K-8 school
serves foreign residents in Hiroshima, most of whom are educators,
missionaries and business people. Some work for the Radiation
Effects Research Foundation. Less than 100 children from some
10 countries attend the school each year. The school also
serves some 600 part-time Japanese students through a variety
of culture and language classes. Teachers have been drawn
from the British Commonwealth, Europe, Japan and the United
States. Our educational goals were four: to help each of our
students return home at or above grade level; to foster care,
creativity and collaboration; to appreciate and understand
local and global culture and the commonalities and diversity
of humankind; and to utilise an active pedagogy not as preparation
for adulthood, but as lived experience itself. We designed
the context: time, space, activities, expectations and standards
of conduct, and ‘curriculum’ in the ways we believed most
suitable to sustain our goals.
August 6, 1985 was the fortieth commemoration
of the atomic bombing of Hiroshima and there was unprecedented
world-wide attention focused on Hiroshima and its residents.
A major U.S. television company wanted to interview American
children living in Hiroshima. They were asked, ‘Do you have
nuclear nightmares?’ ‘Do you feel guilty being an American
living in Hiroshima?’ ‘Do Hiroshima hibakusha (bomb victims)
despise you?’ These questions, which most adults would find
it difficult to respond to, became the basis for foreign children
living in Hiroshima to start a world-wide peace movement.
They had no easy or politically correct answers. But their
attempts to resolve conflicting perspectives did raise a question
articulated by Kim Blackford, then age twelve, ‘Kids don’t
start wars. But what can kids really do for peace?’
The personal anguish we felt was over our
inability to help constructively, to reach out for Hiroshima
and the bomb victims. But help whom? Affectively, at least,
we are all A-bomb victims. And what we uncover from the past
of which we were not part is a reconstruction that somehow
is embedded in the present of our meaning-making. The message
of Hiroshima, gnawing at our consciences is not simply in
the past; it is the past in the present as our future.
a sacred bird
The white crane is the sacred bird of Japan. Legend tells that
it lives for a thousand years and that anyone who folds a
thousand paper cranes will also live a long life. Most Japanese
children also know the life story of Sadako Sasaki and the
Paper Crane Club, which helped to make the paper crane a vibrant
symbol of the hope for peace.
Sadako was two years old when the atomic
bomb was dropped on Hiroshima on August 6, 1945. She was not
burned, but radiation poisoning caused her to contract leukemia
at the age of twelve. Hospitalised, she began folding paper
cranes; she folded more than a thousand paper cranes with
the help of friends, hoping she would get well. She died several
months later.
a new monument
Her seventh-grade classmates wanted to build a monument to
Sadako and the thousands of other children who had died or
were still dying from the bombing. Largely on their own, they
organised a fund raising campaign. They asked children in
Japan and thirteen countries to contribute the equivalent
of five cents. More than three thousand Japanese schools and
hundreds of foreign schools contributed, and in 1958 they
had received enough to build a child-spirited structure in
the middle of Peace Park topped by Sadako’s statue holding
aloft a crane. At its base the monument reads THIS IS OUR
CRY THIS IS OUR PRAYER TO BUILD PEACE IN THE WORLD.
Sadako’s classmates also formed the Paper
Crane Club, which continues today and involves students keeping
the area around the Children’s monument clean, and bestowing
necklaces of cranes on visitors.
The International School students started
thinking. Maybe we too could start a club. Why not contact
kids around the world and tell them the stories of Sadako
and the Paper Crane Club? People place millions of cranes
at the base of the monument each year but you never saw an
accompanying banner of the person or group who placed them
there in any language but Japanese. Why not ask other kids
from around the world to send cranes to be placed by us at
the base of the Children’s Monument? Maybe it would start
an activity that would help keep Hiroshima’s message of peace
in the minds of children all the time, not only on special
anniversaries.
global communities
A club would give foreign children living in Japan a chance
to take part in the local and global communities, communicating
with children from other countries, finding out what they
were thinking and doing, all linked together by a common project.
It seemed like a good idea because, like Sadako’s original
cranes and the response of her classmates, it sprang spontaneously
from a sincere wish to do something about a situation that
seems hopelessly beyond a child’s influence. It was a manifestation
of social concern, of creativity, of the urge to reach out
across barriers of space and culture to become part of a larger
community. It held the promise of taking the children beyond
themselves.
The belief that good teaching empoweres children
to have wonderful ideas and supports them to follow through
and actualise their creations.
At the beginning of the school year in September
1985, the Hiroshima International School community voted that
the 1000 Crane Club would become an integral feature of each
class and of the school as a whole. Teachers would provide
open class time for the project, be accepting of its expansion
and integration into other domains, and would facilitate,
but not dictate, what would happen with the activities and
direction of the project. As much as possible the club would
be children’s living social studies, consonant with the school’s
emphasis on self-governance and the experiential study of
Japanese culture and history. The students would research
and publish a booklet on Hiroshima and Sadako and ask students
to form 1000 Crane Clubs around the world. The children also
decided the school’s Club would emphasise hands-on project
extensions, cross-age work and teaching, debate and discussion
of moral and social dilemmas, conflict mediation and resolution
skills, role-playing and simulations, and arts and crafts.
We decided as a community that each member
would learn to fold a crane, at least as a Japanese craft.
No one had to fold cranes ‘for peace’ (interpreted as folding
cranes to go into the 1000 Crane Club booklet). We decided
as a staff that active discussion of war and peace and the
nuclear debates would arise only from the concerns of students
themselves. The horror of Hiroshima and the anxieties of a
potential holocaust would not be initiated by teachers; we
would fervently support any discussion and exploration initiated
by the students. However, teachers agreed the concepts of
conflict and conflict resolution would be active and prominent
features of our education program, as would the study of critical
thinking, debate, advertising, and propaganda; and the history
of a place, now called Hiroshima.
Part of our reluctance for a nuclear-horror
approach to peace education was that it was an emotional and
cognitive imposition. Hiroshima City’s Peace Curriculum, which
we were invited to adopt and which was required of all City
elementary schools, begins in first grade with a typical lesson
showing children drawings of the horrors of war, including
bodies in flames, with the admonition, ‘War is terrible! War
is wrong, isn’t it?’ While we agreed with the evil and inhumanity
of war, we were bothered by the admonish-and-scare-them-to-believe-in-peace
tactics.
On the other hand, we weren’t living survivors
of the atomic firebomb as were the writers of the curriculum.
From our limited and perhaps naive perspective, peace was
not the simple abolition of war and conflict. Peace was a
way of life, an attitude toward self and others. How can we
help children resolve conflicts more reasonably and humanely?
If conflicts and problems are essential for growth, then collaborative
conflict resolution and problem solving would become essential
activities of our ‘peace club.’ Our greatest concern was to
avoid simply talking about peace but to actualise it within
the cooperative and collaborative ethos of our community.
Preach little. Practice what we value a lot.
On October 25, 1985, the thirtieth anniversary
of Sadako’s death, the 1000 Crane Club was born. The students
had spent over a month researching and planning their 1000
Crane Club booklet, which contains letters to students and
teachers, a bibliography on Hiroshima, the story of Sadako,
illustrations on paperfolding, and an actual paper crane.
Hundreds of booklets were sent to important leaders and organisations
and to Sadako’s parents and members of the Paper Crane Club
who were present. Then we waited. Within the year hundreds
of groups had written to receive the booklet, and by the end
of 1986, when UNESCO’s Courier published a story on Sadako
and the 1000 Crane Club, we had received a first 1000 cranes
from a school in the United States, and in return, we had
sent them a photograph and certificate of membership. The
Club was launched.
The story of Sadako and the Paper Crane Club
is powerful on many levels. It illustrates a grim truth about
nuclear weapons and symbolises a fear of nuclear war that
has been a part of many children’s and adults’ consciousness
for more than two generations. It is also the story of a young
person’s patience, courage, hope and creative activism in
the face of the ultimate fear of pain and death. Sadako’s
story is the tale of the power of children working together
in partnership for a common cause. Groups of children folded
paper cranes, started a movement, raised funds, built a monument,
and established paper cranes as a globally recognised symbol
of hope and the wish for peace. The story thereby opened a
channel for the creative, peaceful expression of fear about
nuclear war in particular, and more generally, it provided
a channel to express deep-felt concern about peoples’ inhumanity
towards others, as well as the hope for a better world.
Sadako’s classmates started a project that
has lasted almost forty years and has become a tradition.
It is a tradition that has grown primarily for the authenticity
of its message. By that I mean it is a natural collaborative
action; it is a non threatening, apolitical, humane way for
children to express feelings that are extremely difficult
to articulate and resolve. And by doing so children can subtly,
yet recognisably, let the adults around them know how much
they care for each other and for their survival. Finally,
the work of Sadako’s classmates, like that of the International
School children’s 1000 Crane Club, has served to give other
children around the world concrete examples of work for and
within peace education.
Conflict, differing opinions, and even animated
arguments were natural phenomena in our Club. From the authenticity
of actively imagining, organising, researching and implementing
a collaborative enterprise, we fostered a context for authentic
growth. The goals of helping and joining others in a 1000
Crane project, locally or globally, leads easily and naturally
to exploring the relationship between international conflict
and peace, between conflict and peacefulness with friends
and family, between our personal ‘internal’ conflicts and
peace of mind. The project provides a natural context for
the exploration of human justice and human rights and the
environmental and people problems of the world. It provides
an ethos for exploring the commonalities and wonderful diversity
of being human, in all its interrelated, cross-cultural, inter
cultural, and multicultural forms. Working together and discussing,
role-playing, or getting involved in conflict in order to
find reasonable, peaceful resolutions create an emotional
paradox that provides an ideal context for significant insights
and social bonding in the classroom.
Whether children are six or twelve, folding
cranes over an extended period of time provides a wonderful
context for discussions and activities of peaceful collaboration.
Whether five or ten minutes per day or several afternoons
a week, to think of Sadako or participation in the 1000 Crane
Club, or to reason about a classroom issue, is to feel and
reason at some point through various mediums about friendship,
fairness and justice, prejudice and equality, empathy and
reciprocity – in short, a whole range of human values. Besides
the value of arts and crafts, and the construction and creation
of new forms, crane-folding sessions become a time to work
together collaboratively, to help or teach others, to work
for a common cause.
Of the many teachers who have written to
us, what is most striking is a common thread – this project
encourages children and adults to enact social values not
often given preference in our competitive, individualistic
schooling. Over the past eight years not only have children
raised monies to translate the booklet in Russian and Japanese
but they have translated excerpts or written their own from
Australia and Sweden to Argentina, India and Mexico. From
hundreds of schools and classrooms in many countries, thousands
of cranes have been sent to be placed at monuments in Peace
Park.
What is absolutely fascinating are the many
wonderful spin-offs of this project, particularly the creative
extensions it fosters in children and their teachers, and
the interconnections made between groups of people. Besides
sending colourful banners to accompany their cranes, groups
have sent to Hiroshima hundreds of drawings, dioramas, collages,
an original play, several video letters, tapes of songs (including
original works), poetry, stories – all expressions of the
human spirit to create, to reach out, and to touch others.
Numerous classrooms and schools and groups have linked with
each other – in some cases classrooms within a building; in
others across town, a region, or a nation or between nations.
Locally and globally inter-culturally linked!
In Argentina various schools throughout the
country sent cranes and then began exchanging students and
projects with each other. In Germany a participating school
created a cultural information exchange (video, artwork) with
a 1000 Crane Club in Sweden. In Sweden a children’s agency
published articles on the club in more than fifty magazines
and newspapers. In Minneapolis groups of second graders each
year teach groups of tenth graders to fold cranes as they
discuss peace and conflict issues in their lives and a group
of dedicated teachers formed a long-term partner linkage between
inner city, suburban and rural schools. The Hands Across the
Seas (HATS) project fosters collaborative research and service
projects including the 1000 Cranes, but also the exchange
of video letters and culture boxes. Each school is also linked
to a partner school in South Africa, Japan, and Russia. Students
in Redwood Falls, over the past five years have folded a thousand
cranes for a peer sick with leukemia at the Mayo Clinic, for
a local retirement home, and for the local families of servicemen
serving during the Persian Gulf War. And in Albuquerque, New
Mexico, students inspired by Sadako’s story decided to erect
a children’s peace statue at Los Alamos, the test site for
the A-bomb.
Most recently in St. Paul, sister city of
Nagasaki, children folded three thousand peace birds, paper
doves, to accompany the first monument from outside Japan
to be placed in Nagasaki’s Peace Park. All of these examples
and stories, and there arehundreds of them, are of ordinary
children collaborating and creating in, sadly, what are still
most often unique situations. By working together in a communal
atmosphere of cooperation for a common good and for the joy
inherent in the task of creating, children, tacitly at least,
are showing adults how much they care to work together actively
and constructively and peacefully.
1000 Crane Club booklet is available
from: ‘Birds of Peace’ United Nations Association of Minnesota,
1929 S. Fifth St., Minneapolis, Minnesota 55454, USA. Price,$10.00.
Instructions on how to make a paper crane
are available on the learnpeace.org.uk website.
Learnpeace
is part of the Unity Project. It is a resource for stories,
projects, and articles about peace. "The education process
and its content are not value free and neither is the material
available here. The value that underpins this site is the
belief that nonviolence is better than violence; that building
a culture of peace should be a priority and a part of this
process is both to question and to challenge our easy acquiescence
in a culture of violence."
More SOS Diaries
Submit a Story:
Do you have a story about raising boys that you would like to share? If so, please consider submitting it as an SOS Diary. It’s a great way to foster discussion about the current issues effecting our sons today.
If you would like to submit your story as an SOS Diary, email members@supportingoursons.org.
|